Bristol Classic Rum Enmore Still 1988

Bristol Classic Rum Enmore Still 1988 rum review by the fat rum pirateBristol Classic Rum are perhaps more famous for their red labelled Port Mo(u)rants.  This 1988 Enmore Still bottling seems to have flown under the radar. It has not attracted anywhere near as much attention.

As this Enmore Still rum was distilled in 1988.  It is likely that it was actually produced on the old Enmore Distillery site rather than Demerara Distiiilers Limited (DDL).  The record books tell me that Enmore Distillery did not cease production completely, until 1993.

In the world of Independent Demerara rum it can be very difficult to judge one bottle from the next.  The Enmore Still used for this should be the EHP (Edward Henry Porter) Continuous Coffey Still.  Which you might think will simplify things…….not entirely.

The EHP still can produce nine unique marques of rum from light to heavy.  From what I can gather this rum is a lighter style.  From speaking with John Barrett (the owner of Bristol Classic Rum) this rum has been aged for 20 years in American Oak (Bourbon Casks) and did not have any kind of finish applied to it.  It spent most of its twenty years ageing here in the UK.

Which along with all the various stills and marques of rum available under the Demerara name adds another factor when it comes to a potential purchase.  Tropical Ageing or Cooler Climate European Ageing.

This rum was bottled way back in 2008.  I’m not quite sure how long after that it was made available.  I have been told that the only remaining bottles are already with the retailers.  There will be no further issues of this particular vintage – this is all Bristol had and its now all gone as far as they are concerned.  I didn’t get tube container with this bottle and the label is more the old style Bristol label.  So it must be a good few years old.

In the UK a bottle of this (if you can find one) will retail at around the £90-95 price point and it is bottled at 43% ABV.

The Enmore Still 1988 is a very light Demerara rum.  Similar in colour to Bristol’s Diamond Distiilery 1998.  A light gold to straw colour.  It is slightly cloudy suggesting no filtering.  The colour also suggests no or minimal caramel was added.  It is often not the bottler who adds the caramel.  DDL are known for adding caramel before the rum is aged.

The nose is pretty big, like the Port Mo(u)rant bottlings, it has a slightly musky, sulphourous note to it.  It’s almost savoury smelling.  Leather and tobacco.  Reassuringly after a little time in the glass you get less sulphur and more balanced oaked aromas. The lighter style of the rum comes through more.  You get a more familiar raisined Demerara note.

Bristol Classic Rum Enmore Still 1988 rum review by the fat rum pirateSipping this rum is a bit of a mixed bag. It starts out fairly light with some sweet fruit notes – raisins and a touch of banana.  It then changes very quickly.  The more oaked notes take over along with some sulphurous chemical like flavour.  These notes overwhelm the palate.

Further sips reveal more of the lighter notes, more fruit for a little longer but again the mid palate and the finish are overwhelmed by the more musty tobacco and almost petrol like notes. You could well believe that this was an experimental blend of Caroni and Demerara.

The finish is very hot and spicy and long lasting.  Its mainly the leather, tobacco and slightly petrol like notes (or fumes) you are left with, unfortunately.

From a personal viewpoint there isn’t enough of the fruity Demerara notes in this rum.  Not enough complexity beyond the oaked notes to make this a really brilliant rum.  It’s not a bad rum but there is a sense that its a little overoaked,  Maybe the lighter rum just wasn’t quite up to 20 years of ageing?  You just get the feeling that one of the components in this rum just hasn’t quite turned out as you might have hoped.  Something has just went a little wrong with this.

It’s a piece of history.  For a 20 year old rum it isn’t really that expensive.  Compared to the Silver Seal Enmore 2002 – this falls quite a way short.  It’s a good authentic rum.  One that I am pleased to have tried but it wouldn’t be one I would buy again.

3 stars

Similar Posts

  • Jamaican Rum JMH Thompson Bros and Bar Tre

    Jamaican Rum JMH Thompson Bros and Bar Tre Rum Review by the fat rum pirateJamaican Rum JMH Thompson Bros and Bar Tre. You might be forgiven for thinking I have already reviewed this. I haven’t the rum I reviewed very recently with a very similar title was JMM rather than JMH. The JMM and JMH I am now assuming to mean JaMaica Monymusk and JaMaica Hampden. As this particular single cask bottling hails from the Hampden Estate, Trelawny, Jamaica.

    There has been no shortage of continentally aged Hampden Estate available for a number of years. In fact until very recently Hampden Estate had never released an aged product. Sounds mad when you think about it but it’s true. Until very recently the only official Hampden Estate release was Rum Fire. An unaged Jamaican Overproof rum.

    The reputation of Hampden Estate rum was built very much on the numerous bottlings sold by various (largely) European based Independent bottlers. Thompson Bros have come slightly late to this particular party but in fairness it’s looking like this could be a week long rave………The appetite for aged Hampden Estate rum, particularly single casks, seems to have no sign of abating.

    I am sure official distillery bottles such as The Great House and collaborations with Habitation Velier sell very well. However, there is still a great deal of kudos to be earned in certain rum circles from owning more exclusive “single cask” bottlings. Some people try to obtain every release. I’ve tried my fair share of Hampden over the years. I like it without question. However like all other rums I’ve never felt the need to go chasing down individuals casks (often from the same batch).  The differences in the overall experience just wouldn’t merit engaging in such a task.

    Anyway that all went a little of piste but to be honest having reviewed a few Thompson Bros bottlings. Including one just last week – I find I sometimes need to cover something a little different in these reviews. To keep things interesting – I hope.

    Anyhow, we’ll cover the pertinent information for this particular bottling. As mentioned we have a Single Cask Rum from Hampden Estate, Jamaica. It was distilled in 2001, so is likely the Diamond H marque (please note I can’t use the arrows used to denote this by Hampden as WordPress has a hissy fit and it affects all the formatting).

    For those who are interested in this sort of thing the Diamond H marque sits at around 900-1000 gr/hl AA or Esters. The Ester count for Hampden rum is anywhere from 40-1600 gr/hl AA. Jamaican Rum JMH Thompson Bros and Bar Tre has been bottled at Cask Strength of 61% ABV. The outturn was 271 bottles. It is 100% Pot Still Jamaican Rum and has been aged for 19 years. The exact locations are not revealed.

    Jamaican Rum JMH Thompson Bros and Bar Tre rum review by the fat rum pirateAs with the previous Jamaican JMM review this is a collaboration between Thompson Bros and Bar Tre, Hiroshima. As a result local Japanese artist Yu Kurahashi. When released (around a week ago) this retailed at around the £140 mark. I’m afraid I can’t find anywhere that still has this for sale. So secondary market again.

    I do suspect you will find a few of these pop up at auction. I think a number of Whisky speculators are chancing their arm at rum. Some have little idea what they are doing. I’m not suggesting that is the case here but unless this bottle gets some kind of mythical status very quickly – I honestly cannot see you having to pay much more (if at all) than retail on the secondary market.

    In the glass we are presented with a light golden brown spirit a shade darker than straw.

    Nosing Jamaican Rum JMH Thompson Bros and Bar Tre it has a very sweet fruity aroma to it. Pineapples, banana, some passion fruit, white grapes and some lychees. Beneath this sweetness is a very “gluey” aroma – kind of like that thick white glue you used to use in school. A touch of Pritt Stick is thrown in for good measure.

    There are notes of cider vinegar and vinegar soaked newspapers (used for wrapping Fish and Chips here in the UK- well they were once upon a time). There is a nice tingle on the nose of oak and a touch of all spice.

    This is a very fruity version of a Hampden and reminds me of Long Pond. Which is no bad thing……..

    The initial sip of this rum is very complicated. There is so much going on. Sweet, sour, and savoury all at the same time! It delivers a slightly tart, acidic but yet very sweet mix of citrus fruit and vinegar. Trust me it tastes better than it sounds……

    There is more wood and spice on the mid palate and the rum leaves a very unusual mixture of nail varnish remover, Pear Drops (boiled sweets with a

    Jamaican Rum JMH Thompson Bros and Bar Tre Rum Review by the fat rum pirate

    very distinct taste) and crystallised fruits. It’s slightly musty on the mid palate as well but all these seemingly different flavour sensations someone meld together into a very enjoyable and very funky glass of rum.

    This seems to combine elements of young unaged Jamaican rum with more aged and developed notes. It’s really quite an intriguing rum. It’s certainly a little bit out there to say the least.

    Finish wise its long and full of all kinds of notes – there is a slightly fermented note which mixes alongside the oak, white pepper and the slightly tart notes of gooseberries and pineapple juice.

    This really does offer something a little different. Apologies I couldn’t get a review out before it sold out. I do try my best.

    Best of luck at the auctions I guess for this one.

     

  • El Dorado Rare Selection

    EL Dorado Rare SelectionOn the 14th January 2016 Demerara Distillers Limited announced their first foray into the world of Cask Strength bottlings.  Except they didn’t, well not directly anyway.

    As of today (15th January 2016) the only place you will readily find information relating to these releases in any kind of “official” capacity is on the Velier website.  Yes I know its in Italian.  So here is a translation (it’s not perfect but you should get the general message)

    In 2016 the Demerara Distillers launches Rare Collection: a limited selection of three single rum alembic and left a full degree. The Demerara Distillers adopted the concept that Velier has created about 15 years ago and in collaboration with the distillery led worldwide, helping to create the myth of Demerara rum. The parent company now makes from s. El Dorado branded, and chose the rum of the three legendary stills in wood, wooden double pot still Port Mourant, the wooden single wooden pot Versailles and column, which they selected coffey Enmore even a 1993. We are happy and excited because the rum are truly amazing, at the level of the selections Gargano, and also at the level of value and growth over time should be considered as analogous (I presume this means they are an investment?).”

    So what do we have here? Three rums from three of the most recognisable stills at Demerara Distillers Limited.  All bottled at cask strength (or near enough) being promoted on the Velier website under the El Dorado label?

    What has this all got to do with Velier?

    Well, first of all Luca Gargano has a financial interest in DDL.  Sometime last year information began leaking out about DDL no longer allowing Velier/Gargano to release Demerara rums under the Velier banner.  Quite what the circumstances were behind this I do not know – I suspect these releases go some way to explain exactly what is going to happen going forward.

    DDL experimented a few years ago with some “Single Barrel” offerings from the EDSINGLEEnmore (EHP), Port Mourant (PM) and Savalle Still’s (ICBU).  However many connessieurs shunned them in favour of independent bottlings as they were only released at 40% ABV.  Those more familiar with El Dorado 12 or 15 were also left largely puzzled by the rums as they weren’t as “sweet” and as approachable as they were used to.  You can read all about them here The Three Amigos from Lance at The Lone Caner

    It seems that they now want a slice of the Independents pie and rather than allow Gargano to continue to release his own bottlings, they have decided to allow him (or forced him or it was his idea?) to use the El Dorado name.

    Now these releases have already garnered quite a lot of excitement.  Which if I’m being honest has left me a little curious.  It also shows just how strong a “known name” can be.

    Whilst these releases would be interesting no matter what “label” was putting them out, it seems they are getting more attention because they are under the El Dorado banner.  Which I find a little strange.  You see your average Velier customer is not keen on El Dorado’s “sugared” offerings.  And your average ED12 and ED15 drinker might not find these rums to their tastes either.  So who is going to buy these?

    Well. firstly it seems that these rums are going to be available solely in Europe.  No US distribution has been confirmed.  Which poses another question.  With the release of the various wine cask finished ED15’s focusing on the US market, do DDL see two very different rum markets?  This must be a concern for any US rum aficionado.

    So just who will be looking to buy these rums on their release?  Well despite my misgivings about Gargano “handing over” these to the El Dorado brand it is clear that most Velier customers will at least embrace one of these bottlings.  Likewise I can see some of these bottlings easily finding their way into the Christmas Boxes of loved ones uitvlugt96who like ED12 and 15.

    My main concern will be with the pricing of these products.  Talk of them being “investments” seems worrying – I drink my rum I certainly don’t collect it.  So I hope this doesn’t make the prices too prohibitive.  Velier prices (still far from cheap) will do just nicely.

    Anyway, I will in the future try my best to source and review these rums.  In the meantime I’m afraid you will have to make do with a few Demerara rum reviews from Velier – which are coming soon to the site.

     

     

     

  • Dead Reckoning Rum Mutiny South Pacific

    Dead Reckoning Rum Mutiny South Pacific Rum Review by the fat rum pirateDead Reckoning Rum Mutiny South Pacific. Another bottling from new Independent bottlers Dead Reckoning. If you aren’t familiar with the brand it is likely because you aren’t living in Australia. Unlike many Independent bottlers Dead Reckoning aren’t based in Europe (or even the US which has seen more Indie bottlers sprout up lately).

    This is the second release from Dead Reckoning, following last years The Sextant, which was a blend of Caribbean rums. Mutiny South Pacific is as the name suggests not a blend from multiple islands/locations. It is a single barrel release of rum from the South Pacific Rum Distillery in Fiji. Much like Flor de Cana and Worthy Park, South Pacific Distillery prefer not to have the distillery named on Independent bottlings.

    In the case of Flor de Cana and South Pacific Distillery this is a little farcical as they usually get bottled as Nicaragua and Fiji. Now I am not entirely sure (and they likely aren’t) if they are the only distilleries in these locations but they are certainly the only ones who export their rums to Independent bottlers.

    Dead Reckoning rums are brought to the market in Australia in conjunction with The Rum Tribe, who are (and I quote) “Australia’s favourite Rum Club”. I was involved in a live tasting of this rum with The Rum Tribe a week or so back. It was quite a lively chat (I did prattle on a bit at times) about Mutiny and all things rum. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

    Anyway, lets get back concentrating on the rum.

    Dead Reckoning Rum Mutiny South Pacific is named after the (in)famous Mutiny on the Bounty, which occured in the South Pacific ocean way back in April 1789. This incident has previously given name to rum in the shape of Captain Bligh XO Rum, which was named after the ships captain at the time of the mutiny. Those involved in the Mutiny settled on Tahiti and Pitcairn Island.

    The rum is from South Pacific Distillery in Fiji. South Pacific Distillery rum two Pot and three Column Stills. I’m not sure of the composition of this rum but I would fancy it is a blend of Pot and Column rums.

    Dead Reckoning Rum Mutiny South Pacific has been aged for eleven years in Fiji at the distillery in an ex-Bourbon barrel and a further six months in Adelaide, Australia in an ex-Cream Apera barrel. For those of you who don’t know (and I confess I didn’t) Cream Aperac is a Fortified Sherry wine. Australia decided to adopt the term “Apera” in 2011 instead of using Sherry, which they felt was disrespectful to Spanish Sherry producers.

    In Australia and The Rum Tribe is the only place you will find this on sale it will set you back $155 dollars. Which works out at around £80 in Pounds/Euros. Baring in mind the high prices of Australian booze. Similar and often much higher than even the UK! This is not bad value at all. In total 400 bottles are/were available.

    The rum has not been bottled at Cask Strength instead it has been brought down to 52% ABV. The original cask samples were around 80% ABV! A loss of 62% Angels Share is noted. With this in mind although a single barrel was shipped to Australia, it is likely that different barrels will have been married together at some stage.Dead Reckoning Rum Mutiny South Pacific Rum Review by the fat rum pirate

    The creator of Dead Reckoning Rum Justin Boseley, is against any kind of sweetening and/or additives in his rums. So this has no additives, colouring etc.

    Dead Reckoning Mutiny South Pacific is dark/golden brown colour with a red tinge around the edges and throughout the rum when swirled in the glass.

    Nosed it has a herbal quality, similar to St Lucian rum. Pine Cones, some Pot Pourri and a touch of eucalyptus.

    Further nosing reveals some molasses, toffee and sweet vanilla. Time in the glass gives more time for the aromas to reveal themselves. Slightly menthol notes appear alongside some light tar and cigarette smoke.

    It’s a complex nose. It’s a rum which is really worth sitting with and nosing. You will get a lot out of it this way and it will also improve your sipping experience. It is both light and soft, yet quite menacing at the same time.

    On the sip it is quite spicy with a fair amount of barrel influence. It’s oaky but the spice from the oak isn’t overly woody. You get a good hit of sweet vanilla and some warming red chilli heat.

    The herbal nature of the rum comes out more with each sip – the pine cones and eucalyptus that was on the nose is very evident. I’m also getting a carbolic/soapy element.

    On the mid palate the rum evolves further. A sooty/tarriness comes through. I think if you experienced a Fijian rum – for the first time you could well think it was a blend. It has elements of St Lucian rum, heavy Caroni and most definitely funky Jamaican notes.

    I haven’t really mentioned the elements which remind me of Jamaican funk. They are definitely there though right from the start. The nose carries elements of Banana Bread, Pineapple and a kind of “mucky” dundery note. The initial sip and mid palate carry a fruitiness as well, which works nicely with the more herbal notes. It keeps the more aggressive elements of this rum at bay. It keeps the balance nicely.

    Dead Reckoning Rum Mutiny South Pacific Rum Review by the fat rum pirateThere’s so much going on with this rum – so it is very much a slow sipper. In terms of overall profile it is one of the longest and most complex rums I have experienced. The finish is long and fades out nicely. However, such is the powerful nature of this rum it leaves behind a fair bit of funk, banana, tar, soot and molasses long after you have sipped it.

    You are probably reading this review wondering if I’m describing about ten different rums and getting my notes mixed up! I’ll be honest with you Fijian rum can be really difficult to try and explain. It certainly can’t be pigeon holed. I’ve not tried this rum prior to it being “double aged” in the Cream Apera barrels but I suspect it has added an extra layer of complexity to the rum and maybe rounded it off a little. Fijian rum can sometimes be a bit too aggressive to be truly enjoyable. This by no means is no shrinking violet but it has a balance of flavour which I’m really enjoying.

    A fascinating rum and easily one of the best Fijian rums I’ve tried. It gets better the more you try it.

  • Our Rum and Spirits W.I.R.D 2000

    Our Rum and Spirits WIRD W.I.R.D Rum Review by the fat rum pirateOur Rum and Spirits W.I.R.D. 2000. Our Rum and Spirits are an Independent bottler from Germany. They were set up by restauranter Christian Nagel who upon discovering how popular rum was becoming with his guests, decided to start importing and distributing rums which would be uniquely his.

    W.I.R.D is the abbreviation of the West Indies Rum Distillery. This has recently been taken over by Alexandre Gabriel of Plantation Rum. Prior to this W.I.R.D only produced the Cockspur brand and survived mostly by selling bulk rum.

    A lot of rum output from the W.I.R.D is column distilled – this rum is believed to be from the Rockley Still. Or at least it is believed to be the Rockley Still style. The Rockley Still is a pot still which is still housed somewhere on the W.I.R.D site. Photos purporting to be the Rockley Still show a still which looks severely neglected and whilst Gabriel hopes to be able to re-activate the still – it doesn’t appear to be very likely from what I’ve seen.

    So how is the Rockley still style re-created? I haven’t got the foggiest to be honest. I assume a Pot Still is used and perhaps someone who may have been around when the Still was active may have lent a hand or at least someone who knows what the rums taste like it produced.

    Rockley Still Style is best described as medicinal. It has more characteristics in common with Caroni Trinidad rum than the more traditional laidback Bajan style. They are unique in many ways and are best described as full blooded.

    There are certain years – 1986 and 2000 where the Rockley Still style of rum has  been produced and vintages of it have been made available to Independent bottlers. Again quite why this is the case – I just don’t know. It may be the 1986 rum is the last to be produced on the actual still. It is believed that the 2000 rums are just in the style of the Rockley Still.

    This was one of the earliest bottlings by Our Rum and Spirits released back in 2015. Only 100 bottles were available. It was bottled at a reasonable 43% ABV and cost around 50 euros from what I understand. Presentation wise it is a little basic but it has relevant information on the bottle and the card sleeve. It was distilled in June 2000 and bottled in December 2014. So its just over 14 years old.

    I only got a sample of this rum and with it being so rare I’ve struggled to find any standard photos online. The bottle pictured isn’t the same rum but the bottle shape etc was the same.

    In the glass Our Rum and Spirits W.I.R.D is a very light amber to straw colour. Even at 43% ABV the nose is quite pungent. It’s pretty medicinal – menthol and eucalyptus. That is offset against a touch of sawdust and some very savoury burnt puff pastry. It has some of the more smoky and tobacco notes you find in Caroni – a touch of motor oil and some really malty notes and some wheaty cereal like notes.

    For all the more aggressive notes and almost whisky like character it does have some lighter sweeter notes. Touches of vanilla and just a hint of brown sugar and Brazil Nuts.

    If I has to guess where this rum is from I wouldn’t say Barbados. Nor would I actually mistake it for a Caroni. It reminds me most of the Fijian rums I have tried. It has those notes of salty brine and olives.

    Sipped Our Rum and Spirits W.I.R.D. is gentler than you might expect from the nose. A nice weight of oak and spiciness and there is a nice honeyed sweetness – a touch of toffee.

    It’s a touch on the bitter side as you move into the mid palate. It’s quite clean and oaky but it doesn’t have a great deal of complexity. The ABV has clipped its wings a little. The finish is pretty short and you get a little shot of Bourbon like spice and a touch of citrus but not for long.

    The nose is more interesting and complex than this rum when sipped. Its much less aggressive when sipped and its quite well balanced. What it does do, it does reasonably well. It just doesn’t really do a great lot.

    I’d have either preferred a stronger ABV as it tastes a little bit watery or a little more sweetness. Overall its a bit too woody for my tastes.

     

     

     

  • Don Papa Rum Aged 10 Years

    Don Papa Rum Aged 10 Years Rum Review by the fat rum pirateDon Papa Rum Aged 10 Years. Alongside Bumbu, Don Papa have become the poster boys for adultered rum masquerading as premium. You could throw a few other rums into the mix, that use additives but Don Papa’s offerings are met with dismay and derision by most serious rum enthusiasts.

    Perhaps the biggest reason for this is the sheer success of the brand. So not content with offering us a 7 Year Old version of their delicious elixir they felt that a further aged version of their wonderous concoction, was just what the rum world needed.

    Presentation wise Don Papa tick all the boxes for the type of Premium rum you will find in department stores such as Harvey Nichols. It is striking and for the average consumer you will see the overall package of this rum and think it is a considerable step up from supermarket offering such as Captain Morgan and Lamb’s. The truth is better rum can easily be found now in UK supermarkets, in the shape of Chairman’s Reserve and Appleton Estate. Amongst others.

    The black and white colour scheme of this rum is offset by and orange labelling on the synthetic cork stopper. A black cork topped cylinder houses the rum. Which comes in a stubby bottle. Don Papa Rum Aged 10 Years has been bottled at 43% ABV. The trusty hydrometer indicates around 16g/L of additives are present. This may seem low but it has been shown in laboratory tests that it also contains glycerin and vanillan. Small amounts are needed to significantly sweeten things up. The hydrometer does not pick up such small amounts of intense flavour.

    Anyone familiar with this site is probably not surprised by my apparent distain for this particular rum. Those of you arriving from a Google Search or visiting for the first time might wonder why I am effectively saying this rum is awful before I even conduct the tasting etc. I usually try not to do this but this brand are one that take the concept of “rum” a step to far. This product is at best a spiced rum and at worst a flavoured neutral spirit.

    It’s popularity is fuelled by a natural human love of sweetness and complete ignorance of what rum actually is. We are sadly still in an age where rum is perceived as sweet as it is produced from sugar.  It is not produced from sugar. It is produced using the by products of sugar production. From the sugar cane. During distillation all the sugar turns to alcohol. Rum is not naturally sweet – at least not to the extent that rums such as Don Papa might lead you to believe.

    This is a rum produced from molasses and aged for 10 years in American oak barrels. Ex-bourbon barrels.

    Don Papa Rum Aged 10 Years Rum Review by the fat rum pirateIn the glass Don Papa Aged 10 Years is a very dark brown. Almost black. It’s a bit of a push to say a 10-year-old rum would be this dark even if it has been aged in Sugarlandia (I am not making that up it’s what they call it).

    The nose is very familiar – huge wafts of raspberry flavoured bubblegum.  Notes of sweet artificial saccharin. Cherry flavoured boiled sweets and a slight hint of some kind of spice trying to break out but its just overpowered by the artificial confected notes.

    It smells like a liqueur – it is ludicrously sweet. It is as far away as a 10-year-old molasses based rum from say Barbados or Jamaica as it is possible. The very idea this can even be labelled as a rum is frankly, a complete embarrassment to the category.

    Sipped you are overwhelmed by a synthetic tart, bitterness. It tastes like a reduced sugar Marmalade. Full of that slightly bitter artificial sweetener like taste.Luckily the huge burst of sugary orange quickly subsides. As does everything else.

    Don Papa Aged 10 Years doesn’t really develop onto anything meaningful. Beyond the sweet/bitter orange on the initial sip you only really experience sweet saccharin notes on the mid palate. There is something which is trying to be oak ageing in there but its just overwhelmed by all the nonsense they have added to this putrid mess.

    An easy comparison – to suggest this is a good rum would be like suggesting Cherry Lambrini is a good wine. No one in the wine community would put up with such nonsense so why the hell does rum put up with bullshit like this? Why will spirit professionals not speak up about this complete and utter insult to rum? Heads in the trough is why. Money, money, money. Wankers.

    Don Papa Rum Aged 10 Years Rum Review by the fat rum pirateFortunately because your taste buds have been assaulted in such a way you probably won’t even notice the finish. It’s very much a blink and you miss it kind of affair. A tiny hint of something sweet and woody – and its gone. All that is left on the palate is artificial bitterness.

    I actually think the No.7 might be better than this. It is as a sipper virtually undrinkable to anyone with a palate. If you are a 12 year old chav with a love for White Lightning and Cinema Pick and Mix then this might be the “rum” for you. However you could buy around 4 litres of Morgan’s Spiced Gold or better still head to Lidl or Aldi for some even cheaper spiced nonsense – for the £50 plus you would pay for this bottled bullshit. For the record I am not advocating any 12 year old’s should be drinking this or any other rum for that matter. My 3-year-old could probably drink this festering gloopy mess it has no alcohol taste to it whatsoever.

    I hate everything about this and the brand. An utter disgrace to rum. A joke in every sense. You will find sadly more favourable reviews online. Here’s a clue they were freebies. Lance over at the Lone Caner was more honest and gave it one of his lowest ever scores. Some of the feelings I have for this have also been expressed by Lance here. The first thing he says is exactly what I thought!

    I hate this so much right now! I was actually given this by someone who had it gifted to them. They couldn’t actually drink this.

    Gateway rum? Gateway to what? It’s certainly not rum that’s for sure.

  • Old Monk Supreme XXX Rum Very Old Vatted

    Old Monk Supreme XXX Rum review by the fat rum pirateThere were a couple of rumours going round the internet last year that Old Monk Rum was going out of production,  It appears those rumours were false. Still I felt it was about time that I published my review of Old Monk Supreme.

    Bought as an impulse purchase online – it had previously been available very briefily and then disappeared again.  I wasn’t going to miss out on this unique Monk shaped bottle again.

    At around £35 and imported from Germany this version of Old Monk Rum is bottled at 42.8% ABV.  Slightly higher than the “regular” Old Monk 7 Year Old.  There is no age statement on this rum it merely states it is “very old vatted”.  It is currently available on Beers of Europe’s website.  They have it noted as being 18 years old.

    From other information (The Rum Howler site) I see that whoever gave Chip his sample must have led him to believe the rum in this bottle is 12 years old.  To be honest I’m not really sure how old any of the Old Monk rums really are.  Due to the lack of information forthcoming from Mohan Meakin, I think they rely on mis-information regarding the age of this rum to help it sell  They never seem to come out and deny or to be fair promote anything!  There are also doubts about a lot of Indian “rum” production and whether it legally should be called rum due to the way it is distilled.

    Old Monk has been the subject of much debate recently.  Both with regard its age statements and constant rumours of its demise.  Some commenters have even suggested that Old Monk may not even be a true rum but flavoured alcohol.  Much like the Croatian Domaci Rum.  I have reviewed an example of this previously here.

    I have been told that the “rum” may well be distilled to above 90% ABV which really makes it ethanol rather than rum which should really be distilled to a maximum of 85% ABV in order to maintain its rum characteristics.  Without any facts to back up any of these claims or comments I will not delve any further into the debate.

    Old Monk Supreme Rum Review by the fat rum pirateSo what I should be faced with here is a older version of the Old Monk 7 Year.  The presentation of the Old Monk Supreme is actually not quite as striking as it first appears.  From a distance it looks fine but closer inspection reveals the bottle to be glass and the head of the monk to be plastic.  Beneath the plastic head is a black screw cap, which to be fair is better than the plastic diffuser used on the 7 year old but still not exactly top notch.  The label around the bottom is actually quite twisted and sloppily stuck especially to the rear.  All in all its pretty cheapo packaging really.  My bottle is intended for the German market only, but I have seen this bottle available to consumers in the US as well.

    In the bottle and the glass the rum takes on the very dark brown, almost black colour of the standard Old Monk.  There is little by way of surprise in the bottle.  Nor is there when the rum is poured into the glass.  The unmistakable (unless you do find a Domaci rum) aroma is 100% Old Monk.  It’s hard to describe really.  It’s a confected smell.  You could imagine smelling boiled sweets like these. It’s very sugary, caramel, toffee, brown sugar.  I like it, its familiar and reminds me very much of the 7 Year Old.  I’ll go as far as to say that without the fortune of having any of the 7 Year Old to compare – it smells pretty much the same.  Is it a kind of Butterscotch perhaps?

    If this rum has been aged for 12 or even 18 years (which I doubt based on price alone) then I should notice a considerable step up between this and the 7 Year Old when sipped.

    Old Monk Supreme Rum Review by the fat rum pirateIt is not noticeably any different flavourwise.  It’s okay as a sipper but the heavy flavour of Old Monk is quite cloying on its own. The extra 2.8% ABV doesn’t make much difference – the rum is certainly not noticeably any stronger.  I would question anyone who would say they could notice such a small difference anyway.

    At £35 I did buy this pretty much for the bottle.  It’s much like Old Monk Rum really – a bit quirky.

    I do enjoy an Old Monk rum and cola.  It’s sweet and tasty as a mixed drink.  Old Monk is very much a molasses, chocolate, toffee sweet rum rather than tropical fruits or lighter notes.  Coffee and cocoa, a little butterscotch.  It’s all good for an easy going sweet mixed drink.  It’s not a hugely rummy rum as mentioned earlier technically it might not even really be rum.  It doesn’t have any oak ageing notes, any vanilla, smokiness or any esters.  It’s just a pleasant sweet drink.  Bit like a spiced rum really.

    I will enjoy this bottle of Old Monk.  Much as I have the 7 Year Old.  Without a direct comparison being available and relying on memory I don’t think much (if anything) has changed between this bottle and the 7 Year Old.  If it has indeed been aged for a further 5 years it has had no impact on the flavour or smoothness.  It really wouldn’t surprise me if this was the same rum.  To be fair nowhere does it claim to be 12 or 18 years old.  No age statement at all!

    As much as I have enjoyed this I couldn’t really recommend buying this over the cheaper 7 Year Old.  The differences aren’t sufficient (if any).  Old Monk (in whatever variant you may come across it) is worth trying, however trying the 7 Year Old is noticeably easier on the wallet.

    For that point alone the Supreme loses half a point.  I could deduct another half for deliberately confusing consumers but I’ll let them off.  Old Monk Supreme isn’t hugely expensive.

    2.5 stars

2 Comments

  1. I have one of these. Interestingly the back label makes reference to it being from the EHP still but the Bristol website says this is distilled on a pot still. The Versaille single wooden pot still was moved to Enmore following the closure of Versaille in 1977 and then again onwards to Uitvlugt in 1993, so between 1977 and 1993 Enmore were running the Versaille pot still – could this be from the Versaille pot still and not the EHP wooden Coffey still? Bit confusing given the difference on the bottle label and the website blurb.

Comments are closed.