Blackwell Fine Jamaican Rum
For those that aren’t aware (and either you haven’t bought this rum before or cannot read – in which case you won’t be able to read this either and come to think of it you wouldn’t be reading my blog…) Blackwell Fine Jamaican Rum is named after Chris Blackwell.
Still none the wiser? Well the Blackwell’s are (so the label tells me) one of Jamaica’s oldest merchant families renowed for exporting banana’s, coconuts and rum. Okay, I’m kidding Chris Blackwell isn’t famous for exporting banana’s. He was the owner of Island Records and he discovered U2 and Bob Marley. So you’ve got him to blame for Bono and No Woman, No Cry.
Blackwell Fine Jamaican Rum is also noted as “Black Gold” and “Special Reserve” on the bottle. The Special Reserve part seems odd as I understand that this is a rum which has only been aged for 1 year. My other bottle of Special Reserve is my El Dorado 15 year old! Blackwell rum cost around £20-25 per bottle which places it in the same price range as Appleton VX/8. It is bottled at 40% ABV.
Blackwell Rum is actually distilled by J Wray and Nephew (who market Appleton Estate amongst others). It is made using an old family recipe and is created by Chris Blackwell and Joy Spence (the master blender at Appleton Estate). Blackwell’s family once owned J Wray and Nephew so the story goes.
The presentation of the Blackwell is actually really good. The bottle is dark brown and has a “lopsided” label, sealed with a wax/plastic seal similar to those used many years ago to seal letters. The wax seal has Blackwells embossed on it. Too much use of the word seal there I fear (and more to come later!) The front label has a Pirate style map of Jamaica and the rear has a picture of a very young looking Chris Blackwell and a little story about the rum’s heritage.
So onto the tasting. Lookswise the rum is pretty much the same colour as the bottle. It is a very dark reddish/brown. It is certainly not the bright orange colour of the younger Appleton’s. The nose is rich, dark molasses and caramel. There is a lot of youth and “booze” in the nose. This doesn’t smell like a refined sipper.
And in indeed it certainly is not a rum for sipping unless you enjoy a strong burn. It is too young and harsh to recommend as anything other than a mixer really. The sweetness of the aroma is overpowered by the youthfulness of the blend and the burn is long lasting and leaves little by way of flavour in the mouth, just heat.
I approached this rum not really knowing what to expect. Some reviewers seem to have concentrated on the Jamaican-ness of this rum. Now admittedly young Jamaican rum’s are quite rough and many a person who enjoys sweeter rum’s cannot get over the aroma and “funk” (it’s the only word that I can think to use!). However, this rum despite its rough edges doesn’t display that distinctive pot still high ester flavour of the younger Appleton’s or Smith and Cross.
In my opinion, of the reviews I have read, many have missed the rum which comes closest in terms of overall taste and profile. It seems odd because at the bottom of the Blackwell label is a reminder – Black Gold.
Once mixed with cola Blackwell Fine Jamaican rum reveals a lot of sweet flavours – caramel, black strap molasses, a little coconut, hints of vanilla. It’s pretty close to a Spiced rum. To my palate the rum it reminds me most of is Goslings Black Seal Bermuda Rum. Comparing this to Appleton just doesn’t work for me. It does have a little Jamaican flavour to it but it isn’t a rum I would personally recommend to a lover of Smith and Cross for instance. It tastes slightly confected like the Black Seal but comes up without added sugar at least in the hydrometer tests. As it is bottled in Jamaica it should be additive free.
This is a relatively inexpensive offering (some reviews note it is quite expensive in the US – it seems fairly reasonable over here).
Overall the rum is fairly reasonable mixing rum. It is enjoyable enough but at its price point there is a lot of competition. Any rum retailing at £20-25 should at least mix well. It isn’t something to sip, maybe over a couple of ice cubes at a push.
Unfortunately for Blackwell despite its cracking presentation and its reasonable price it’s direct competition – Appleton, offer a different more authentic Jamaican experience entirely as do most Jamaican Rums. This only really leaves it appealing to lovers of Goslings Black Seal. I keep being reminded of Sailor Jerry but I fancy that is because the Blackwell bottle is similar. This isn’t a sweet or vanilla-ey as our favourite Tattoo Artists offering.
In my view this isn’t as good as Goslings Black Seal or Appleton VX. It’s not a bad rum but it would need a heavy discount say to £15 per bottle to make me buy anymore.
Very average


Dead Reckoning Barbados PX. We continue our recent reviews of Independent bottlers with a review from the other side of the world. Today we have a rum from Aussie bottlers Dead Reckoning. I’ve covered quite a few of their releases over the past few years.
As a result the finish is drier and less sweet than you might have expected from the initial sip. The difference between the initial sip and the finish is quite noticeable and its almost as if you are getting two rums for the price of one! The finish is almost like a bourbon.
Foursquare Convocation. If like myself you have a fairly limited lexicon with regards to Latin and words derived from it you’ll have no idea what a Convocation might be. It might not even come from Latin for all I know.
The finish as you would expect from a 62% spirit is long and very, very good. It reminds of the everlasting gobstopper scene in Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory….theres just so much going on and it never seems to completely fade.
Plantation Rum should need little introduction. Part of Cognac Ferrand, they finish and/or age rum they procure from all around the globe in cognac and other wine casks.
pretty dusty bottle from a local off licence just a few months ago (October 2015). I went for this over the other Plantation’s on offer as it was the only one I could identify as no longer being available. The world has now moved onto the 2001 edition of this rum. A 2001 edition of this rum will set you back around £40.
The only hope I feel this rum will have is a mixer. It’s amazing how some rums really work as mixers even when they fall short as sippers.
Dràm Mòr Single Cask Rum Diamond Distillery Aged 10 Years. I said when reviewing the Dràm Mòr Fiji bottling a couple of days ago that I would get their other Spring release reviewed as quickly as I could. So here we are…….
At 10 years old the finish is decent enough but it does fade out a little quicker than I might have hoped. It becomes almost a little hoppy in parts and it feels a little like an aged bourbon.
Jamaica Cove Black Ginger Rum. I’ve noticed a few Ginger flavoured rums appear on the market over the past couple of years. We’ve always tried on this site to help with people’s curiosity when usual or different rums appear. Especially when they are priced at the mid and lower end of the market.
But really I wasn’t expecting this to be a stellar sipping experience. I was expecting to end up mixing this rum. Which is where you will have few complaints. It makes a really good Dark and Stormy when mixed with Ginger Beer – Ginger Ale works well also. Surprisingly the drink doesn’t become overpoweringly ginger.
Cane Island Dominican Republic Aged 5 Years is the final review in the recently released trio of rums from Cane Island.
Very few indie bottlers have put out any Dominican rum. This rum is aged for 5 years and has been column distilled at “Alcoholes Finos Dominicanos” the distillery location noted on the bottle is “San Pedro de Macoris”. Which is the distillery which produces the Ron Barceló brand amongst others.
I have only had this once, and it reminded me (without directly having them side by side) of Myers’s Dark. How do you compare the two?
I much prefer Myers’s to be honest. This is a bit softer
It is a spiced rum..
While since I did this review. Not sure if they ever came out and said it was spiced but definitely flavoured in some way. Family recipe